Parenting Forums
Hot Topics

    Parents Forum

    ,

    Parenting Community

    ,

    Pregnancy Forums

    , &

    Parenting Resources

    Go Back   Parenting Forums > Developmental/Parenting Stages > Adolescence/Puberty
    Closed Thread
     
    Thread Tools Display Modes
    Old 03-04-2012, 09:42 PM   #1
    Scott
    Junior Member
     
    Join Date: Jun 2011
    Posts: 11
    Rep Power: 0
    Reputation: 10
    Scott has disabled reputation
    Children: 2 boys: 12yo and 15yo
    Default Spanking Teenagers

    I'm curious to hear what other parents' views are on spanking teenagers. I have two sons, ages 12 and 15. Although they're both generally well-behaved, even they need to be disciplined from time to time. This has usually involved grounding them or taking away privileges. However, I've come to realize that these kinds of measures don't always work so well. I think that in some instances a harsher punishment is called for.


    So recently I've been pondering whether or not I should introduce spanking as another means of discipline to be used in certain circumstances. I've given it a good deal of consideration myself, but I'd like to hear your thoughts on the matter as well.


    Now I realize that spanking can be a controversial topic, especially when it comes to older children such as my own. Again, the ages of my sons are 12 and 15. So that's one teen and one preteen. Please let me know what your opinions are on this subject and whether you think there are situations where spanking teenagers can be acceptable. If you feel that gender is important, remember that both of my children are boys so please focus your responses on teenage boys rather than girls.
    Scott is offline  

    Advertisement [Remove Advertisement]
    Old 03-04-2012, 10:16 PM   #2
    cybele
    PF Addict
     
    Join Date: Feb 2012
    Location: Australia
    Posts: 1,629
    Rep Power: 192
    Reputation: 3611
    cybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond repute
    Children: Dita (19) Azriel (17) Sunny (14) Lux (12) Sasha (6)
    Default Re: Spanking Teenagers

    Im not a 'spanking parent' but I dont disgree with it in young children.

    However, I feel that a 12yr old is really quite borderline, I dont think its an appropriate time to start, id say its the time to end it. 15, for me, out of the question no.

    I think 12 and 15 are now at an age where you can have deeper level conversations, thsy can understand more complex ideas so I dont think there is reason to spank a teenager other than for power (which isnt right in ths first place)
    cybele is offline  
    Old 03-04-2012, 11:00 PM   #3
    Scott
    Junior Member
     
    Join Date: Jun 2011
    Posts: 11
    Rep Power: 0
    Reputation: 10
    Scott has disabled reputation
    Children: 2 boys: 12yo and 15yo
    Default Re: Spanking Teenagers

    Thanks for those thoughts, cybele. I realize that the ages are quite borderline, which is why I've given this so much consideration.


    As far as having deeper conversations with them, I wholeheartedly agree. I think communicating with your teens and discussing things with them is one of the most effective ways of parenting them. But I guess what I was really asking about was an actual punishment. While a conversation is certainly a good starting point, I wouldn't consider it a substitute for, say, a grounding. I think some cases call for an actual consequence in addition to a good conversation.
    Scott is offline  
    Old 03-05-2012, 03:14 AM   #4
    singledad
    PF Addict
     
    singledad's Avatar
     
    Join Date: Oct 2009
    Location: South Africa
    Posts: 1,648
    Rep Power: 433
    Reputation: 9278
    singledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond repute
    Children: 1 girl, 7 years old and 1 boy, born 11 Dec 2013
    Default Re: Spanking Teenagers

    I agree wholeheartedly with cybele re. them being too old for spanking, and especially too old to start now. My guess is that you'd only trigger more rebellion if you start spanking now.

    Unfortunately you don't give examples of what you wish to punish them for, so its a bit difficult to really give suggestions for alternatives. Basically - if its just normal teenage stuff like neglecting chores, being disrespectful, missing curfew etc, I'd simply let them feel the natural consequences of their actions, of course, coupled with a discussion on exactly why you object to their behavior, what the consequences are, and what you expect from them instead...

    Of course, if its more than average teenage stuff (I'm talking criminality, acting out in, or skipping school to the point where their school marks suffer, etc) I'd say some investigation is needed into why they do what they do. Solutions are always more effective if they address the cause, and not just the symptoms.
    singledad is offline  
    Old 03-05-2012, 07:38 AM   #5
    mom2many
    Super Moderator
     
    mom2many's Avatar
     
    Join Date: Jul 2008
    Location: melba, Idaho
    Posts: 3,781
    Rep Power: 857
    Reputation: 18604
    mom2many has a reputation beyond reputemom2many has a reputation beyond reputemom2many has a reputation beyond reputemom2many has a reputation beyond reputemom2many has a reputation beyond reputemom2many has a reputation beyond reputemom2many has a reputation beyond reputemom2many has a reputation beyond reputemom2many has a reputation beyond reputemom2many has a reputation beyond reputemom2many has a reputation beyond repute
    Children: Ted (22), Samantha (21), Lupan (20), Megan (19), Cole (12), Vanna (9), Aiden (6), Kailyn 3 years
    Default Re: Spanking Teenagers

    They are at the age where there are other measures that can be used and be much more effective.
    __________________
    mom2many is offline  
    Old 03-05-2012, 09:23 AM   #6
    Xero
    Super Moderator
     
    Xero's Avatar
     
    Join Date: Mar 2008
    Location: PA
    Posts: 7,891
    Rep Power: 1187
    Reputation: 24761
    Xero has a reputation beyond reputeXero has a reputation beyond reputeXero has a reputation beyond reputeXero has a reputation beyond reputeXero has a reputation beyond reputeXero has a reputation beyond reputeXero has a reputation beyond reputeXero has a reputation beyond reputeXero has a reputation beyond reputeXero has a reputation beyond reputeXero has a reputation beyond repute
    Children: Two boys, 6 years old and 2 years old
    Default Re: Spanking Teenagers

    Absolutely not. Agree with the above.
    __________________
    Xero is offline  
    Old 03-05-2012, 09:25 PM   #7
    Scott
    Junior Member
     
    Join Date: Jun 2011
    Posts: 11
    Rep Power: 0
    Reputation: 10
    Scott has disabled reputation
    Children: 2 boys: 12yo and 15yo
    Default Re: Spanking Teenagers

    Thanks for the opinions everyone.

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by singledad View Post
    if its just normal teenage stuff like neglecting chores, being disrespectful, missing curfew etc, I'd simply let them feel the natural consequences of their actions, of course, coupled with a discussion on exactly why you object to their behavior, what the consequences are, and what you expect from them instead...
    Yes, I would say it is "normal teenage stuff" and not something more serious like criminal behavior. Problem is, I've tried exactly what you and others have suggested, i.e. verbally addressing the situation and allowing them to feel the natural consequences of their actions, and I haven't seen any improvement in behavior. I've told my son to be home at a certain time, addressed it with him when he hasn't, only to see the same thing happen again. I think part of the problem is that there really aren't any natural consequences to such behavior.


    I just feel like I need assert myself more and show them who's in charge. I don't think spanking is a perfect solution, but I do think it would definitely shake things up and make a bold statement, unlike my past attempts. Whether it's ultimately effective only time will tell. But I feel like it's at least worth a shot.
    Scott is offline  
    Old 03-05-2012, 10:00 PM   #8
    singledad
    PF Addict
     
    singledad's Avatar
     
    Join Date: Oct 2009
    Location: South Africa
    Posts: 1,648
    Rep Power: 433
    Reputation: 9278
    singledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond reputesingledad has a reputation beyond repute
    Children: 1 girl, 7 years old and 1 boy, born 11 Dec 2013
    Default Re: Spanking Teenagers

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Scott View Post
    I think part of the problem is that there really aren't any natural consequences to such behavior.
    There aren't? So you can abuse freedom and trust and there are no consequences? You can abuse privileges and still keep them?

    Dude, You need to think more laterally.

    Unless your mind is made up, that is. And your last paragraph certainly makes it look like it is...
    singledad is offline  
    Old 03-05-2012, 10:54 PM   #9
    Scott
    Junior Member
     
    Join Date: Jun 2011
    Posts: 11
    Rep Power: 0
    Reputation: 10
    Scott has disabled reputation
    Children: 2 boys: 12yo and 15yo
    Default Re: Spanking Teenagers

    My mind isn't made up, that's why I'm here. But I will say I'm leaning more towards trying it than I had in the past.


    And as far as misbehavior not having natural consequences, my point was that there's much less of a cause-and-effect between typical teen misbehavior and consequences vs. more serious/criminal behavior and its consequences. If a teen starts taking drugs, he can get addicted or spend time in jail. If he doesn't do his chores...well then the chores just don't get done. In cases like this, it falls on the parents to actually create consequences or else there won't be any.
    Scott is offline  
    Old 03-06-2012, 02:16 AM   #10
    cybele
    PF Addict
     
    Join Date: Feb 2012
    Location: Australia
    Posts: 1,629
    Rep Power: 192
    Reputation: 3611
    cybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond reputecybele has a reputation beyond repute
    Children: Dita (19) Azriel (17) Sunny (14) Lux (12) Sasha (6)
    Default Re: Spanking Teenagers

    When my kids leave dirty dishes around the house they find them on their beds. When they dont wash their clothes they go to school smelling and get picked on. When they dont clean their rooms mice wake them up in the middle of the night.

    I really dont think spanking will get you anywhere, to start spanking a 15yr old, id say it would probably end in the 15yr old claiming abuse.
    cybele is offline  
    Closed Thread


    Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
     
    Thread Tools
    Display Modes

    Posting Rules
    You may not post new threads
    You may not post replies
    You may not post attachments
    You may not edit your posts

    BB code is On
    Smilies are On
    [IMG] code is On
    HTML code is Off

    Forum Jump

    Similar Threads
    Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
    Judge WIlliam: More fuel for the spanking debate parentastic Parenting Debate 10 11-09-2011 01:13 AM
    What age do you stop spanking? NinJaBob Parenting Debate 122 09-05-2011 11:22 AM
    Spanking Children meow_173 Parenting Debate 74 09-06-2009 04:47 AM
    How Parents can understand Teenagers Father Blogger General 10 04-08-2009 08:07 AM
    Spanking... Dadu2004 Parenting Debate 54 10-21-2008 11:48 AM


    All times are GMT -7. The time now is 04:24 AM.
    Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
    Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.