Child dies of untreated diabetes - should the parents be arrested?...

Ari2

PF Fiend
Jan 7, 2008
1,513
0
0
<r>I've been following this because it is in my state:<br/>
<br/>
<COLOR color="Navy"><s></s><B><s></s> Girl dies of treatable diabetes after parents pick prayer over medicine<e></e></B><br/>
AP, March 27, 2008<br/>
<br/>
WESTON, Wis. - Police are investigating an 11-year-old girl’s death from an undiagnosed, treatable form of diabetes after her parents chose to pray for her rather than take her to a doctor.<br/>
<br/>
An autopsy showed Madeline Neumann died Sunday from diabetic ketoacidosis, a condition that left too little insulin in her body, Everest Metro Police Chief Dan Vergin said.<br/>
<br/>
She had probably been ill for about a month, suffering symptoms such as nausea, vomiting, excessive thirst, loss of appetite and weakness, the chief said Wednesday, noting that he expects to complete the investigation by Friday and forward the results to the district attorney.<br/>
The girl’s mother, Leilani Neumann, said the family believes in the Bible and that healing comes from God, but she said they do not belong to an organized religion or faith, are not fanatics and have nothing against doctors.<br/>
<br/>
She insisted her youngest child, a wiry girl known to wear her straight brown hair in a ponytail, was in good health until recently.<br/>
"We just noticed a tiredness within the past two weeks," she said Wednesday. "And then just the day before and that day (she died), it suddenly just went to a more serious situation. We stayed fast in prayer then. We believed that she would recover. We saw signs that to us, it looked like she was recovering."<br/>
<br/>
Her daughter — who hadn’t seen a doctor since she got some shots as a 3-year-old, according to Vergin — had no fever and there was warmth in her body, she said.<br/>
<br/>
The girl’s father, Dale Neumann, a former police officer, said he started CPR "as soon as the breath of life left" his daughter’s body.<br/>
<br/>
Family members elsewhere called authorities to seek help for the girl.<br/>
<br/>
"My sister-in-law, she’s very religious, she believes in faith instead of doctors ...," the girl’s aunt told a sheriff’s dispatcher Sunday afternoon in a call from California. "And she called my mother-in-law today ... and she explained to us that she believes her daughter’s in a coma now and she’s relying on faith."<br/>
<br/>
The dispatcher got more information from the caller and asked if an ambulance should be sent.<br/>
<br/>
"Please," the woman replied. "I mean, she’s refusing. She’s going to fight it. ... We’ve been trying to get her to take her to the hospital for a week, a few days now."<br/>
<br/>
The aunt called back with more information on the family’s location, emergency logs show. Police and paramedics arrived within minutes and immediately called for an ambulance that took her to a hospital.<br/>
But less than an hour after authorities reached the home, Madeline — a bright student who left public school for home schooling this semester — was declared dead<br/>
<br/>
...<br/>
<br/>
<B><s></s>Prayer exemption in Wisconsin state law<e></e></B><br/>
<br/>
WESTON -- Many questions have been raised about whether the Madeline Neumann's parents will be blamed for their daughter's death.<br/>
<br/>
The District Attorney's office has yet to receive the full report, but one legal expert says this is a complicated issue. <br/>
<br/>
A UW Madison scholar has recently written a book dealing specifically with prayer as it relates to the law. <br/>
<br/>
Shawn Peters says it's very unlikely that Neumann's parents would be charged with murder, but manslaughter, neglect, and abuse are still on the table.<br/>
<br/>
But he says one state statute makes it very difficult to decide what should be done legally. That's because it contains an exemption referred to as "the treatment through prayer".<br/>
<br/>
Peters says, "It becomes far more complicated when you deal with the interests of children, and literally life or death issues, that's when statutes like this are sort of called into question."<br/>
<e>
</e></COLOR><COLOR color="Navy"><s></s><br/>
<e>
</e></COLOR><br/>
&lt;FONT font="Arial"&gt;&lt;s&gt;<FONT font="Arial">&lt;/s&gt;&lt;br/&gt;
&lt;e&gt;
&lt;/e&gt;&lt;/FONT&gt;&lt;/r&gt;
 

meow_173

PF Addict
Jan 3, 2008
3,957
0
0
38
Hamilton, Ontario
Should they be arrested? I think so. Neglegent HOmicide. God does not interviene in every situation. Divine miracles do not happen every day. If my child was dying, and i would want her to live, i'm sure "god" would understand that i would want what was best for my child
 

musicmom

PF Visionary
Dec 4, 2007
8,923
0
0
My personal belief is yes they should but then again you are invading their constitutional rights. Although.....that leaves the door open for any parent that has a child to allow that child to get sick and do nothing.
They allow people to not get blood transfusions because of their religious beliefs and they still die and the law does nothing.
No matter, I think the law(state) will pick it up and prosecute for child neglect. They will aruge that the power of prayer works but God also gave us free will and their free will needed to take over.

Do they have any other children? They should serve time without a doubt.
 

Amber

PF Addict
Feb 8, 2008
1,826
0
0
44
Knoxville, TN
God gave us doctors and medical knowledge for a reason. For us to put it to use.

Yes, I think they should be held accountable.
 

Ari2

PF Fiend
Jan 7, 2008
1,513
0
0
musicmom said:
Do they have any other children? They should serve time without a doubt.
They do have other children, and these kids have been taken away from them. Currently, the DA is trying to decide what charge to bring.

I think they should be charged with negligent homicide (Wisconsin doesn't have a manslaughter charge) and child neglect.

I can't understand these parents. It sounds like the girl suffered for a month before she died. He's a former police officer, so it is likely he received instruction on diabetic emergencies such as DKA. Regardless, the girl had to have been really sick. How can parents do that? :(
 

Skyburning

PF Fiend
Oct 6, 2007
1,736
0
0
Mississippi
Yes, I didn't even think twice when I read this story. They should have charges brought against them and maybe even have the other children removed from the home. Does anyone know if the girl every said whether or not she wanted to see a doctor?
 

Amber

PF Addict
Feb 8, 2008
1,826
0
0
44
Knoxville, TN
Skyburning said:
Does anyone know if the girl every said whether or not she wanted to see a doctor?

Could she have, and had her request granted? I know they can't say who they'd want to live with during a divorce proceeding at that age. Just curious.
 

Ari2

PF Fiend
Jan 7, 2008
1,513
0
0
Skyburning said:
Does anyone know if the girl every said whether or not she wanted to see a doctor?
It would have been hard for her to do so. She was homeschooled, and the family lives in a very rural area. She was 11 and hadn't seen a doctor since she was 3.

But there were several adults who tried to get help. After the child couldn't walk or talk the maternal grandmother urged the mother to take her to help. The mother said she "would be fine and God would heal her". The grandmother than contacted a daughter-in-law in California, who called the police. The police sent an ambulance. Immediately before that, some family friends in the home called 911 and said the girl had stopped breathing. Unfortunately, she was dead by the time the ambulance arrived.
 

Skyburning

PF Fiend
Oct 6, 2007
1,736
0
0
Mississippi
Amber said:
Could she have, and had her request granted? I know they can't say who they'd want to live with during a divorce proceeding at that age. Just curious.
The reason I ask is because if the girl had every made mention of wanting medical attention then the parents should be prosecuted to the fullest extent.
 

budnkota

PF Fanatic
Mar 28, 2008
683
0
0
47
Indiana
I am curious where we draw the line. I think it's nuts - but people like this TRULY beleive that God will intervene, that enough prayer will solve the problem. I don't know much about how this would come on - perhaps they simply didn't realize how serious it was until it was too late?

I also wonder how insulin (though I'm guessing parents had no idea she was diabetic) works with certain religions... doesn't it come from pigs usually? Maybe I am wrong about that - but if not, there could be major religious implications there.

If a relative tried to just take her to a doctor, they could be looking at a kidnapping charge - and a doc (unless in an ER if deemed life threatening at that time) may not treat her without parental permission.
If you can refuse your child a transfusion or transplant for religious reasons, I would imagine that you could also refuse to seek medical care at all. I don't know how states would be able to say one thing is OK and not another... Either way, that is terribly sad.
(sorry - kind of a rambling post, couldn't organize my thoughts today)
 

Ari2

PF Fiend
Jan 7, 2008
1,513
0
0
budnkota said:
I also wonder how insulin (though I'm guessing parents had no idea she was diabetic) works with certain religions... doesn't it come from pigs usually? Maybe I am wrong about that - but if not, there could be major religious implications there.
Insulin for humans used to be derived from pig or cow insulin. Bovine-based insulin hasn't been available in the US for a while, and the FDA banned the use of porcine-based insulin since February of 2006. The insulins used now are human insulin analogs, created in labs.
 

Kaytee

PF Deity
Apr 9, 2007
7,204
0
0
44
Texas
wow I have to say I don't know. I do believe in the power of God to heal, when he deems it, but to not take your seriously ill child to the doc.
I would not say it is murder, they obviously loved the child and did not want her to die, but I cna't say they should get off either
 

musicmom

PF Visionary
Dec 4, 2007
8,923
0
0
I really have a hard time believing two parents can be that stupid. There has to be more to this story. If it were MY family I would have made a way to take the child to the ER and faced charges later.
 

hwnorth

PF Fanatic
Mar 13, 2008
934
0
0
55
Courtenay BC Canada
I think this is one of the keys to religion...

Many people follow "blind faith". This was a medical emergency that required medical intervention .. YET.... blind faith had them believe that a mythical figure would save their daughter.

This is just one example of many as to why the depths of religion or looked down upon by so many. Faith is one thing... allowing your child to die is yet another.

Can I see giving it a couple days of "faith healing" ? Sure ... but letting your child suffer for a month ? ... Charge Them !!!
 

Kaytee

PF Deity
Apr 9, 2007
7,204
0
0
44
Texas
This is just one example of many as to why the depths of religion or looked down upon by so many.
only 12% of the population has no religion, plus 1% that are athiest, so I don't see how you can say "so many" look down upon religion. Christianity while falling, is still the highest percentage religious group, but looking at all other religions, again only 12 percent are non believers.


of course this is not what the debate is about
 

hwnorth

PF Fanatic
Mar 13, 2008
934
0
0
55
Courtenay BC Canada
Kaytee said:
only 12% of the population has no religion, plus 1% that are athiest, so I don't see how you can say "so many" look down upon religion. Christianity while falling, is still the highest percentage religious group, but looking at all other religions, again only 12 percent are non believers.


of course this is not what the debate is about
What area are these stats from ? I know in the USA there are some extremely strong religious areas. I should have specified organized religion though
 

Kaytee

PF Deity
Apr 9, 2007
7,204
0
0
44
Texas
I just pulled it of the worlds religion. I'll go get it.
I do still agree that something needs to be done about this family. But just like the crazy readical muslims, a small few give the rest a bad name
 

Ari2

PF Fiend
Jan 7, 2008
1,513
0
0
Kaytee said:
I would not say it is murder, they obviously loved the child and did not want her to die, but I cna't say they should get off either
In Wisconsin (the state that this happened), "reckless homicide" is defined as causing the death of another person under circumstances that show "utter disregard for human life". The child suffered greatly for an extended period of time, and the parents refused to call for help even when the grandmother asked them to. I think they should be arrested for reckless homicide. I doubt they wanted her to die, but by not even picking up the phone to call a doctor they showed utter disregard.

I agree, Kaytee, that a parent needs to take their seriously ill child to the doctor, regardless of one's belief in the power of prayer. It is awful that these parents refused to do that.
 

Kaytee

PF Deity
Apr 9, 2007
7,204
0
0
44
Texas
its kinda scary. I mean I love my God, I feel very lucky to have him in my life. But he is not here to take care of my child. He is here to protect us, sure, but not to that extent. Prayer does not hurt, regardless of your religious beliefs, but just prayer can hurt. Sometimes God wants us to get off our butts and do the work we need to do