I voted Yes and No because I think if you look hard enough you can always find the good AND the bad in every situation.
I am the oldest of four children, and my mom basically raised us all on her own. My mom and dad never married, he even to this day (30 years later) is still afraid they might get into some huge fight and want to divorce. Well, they've gotten into tons of huge fights, and unfortunately they're still together.
We had to move around a LOT as a kid, up until the end of the third grade I hadn't lived in any single place for more than a couple of months. This was due to my mom having to move from one job to another to support us, or having to go where the housing authority put us. We were on food stamps, my mom was in work programs, sometimes working two jobs. That wasn't easy for her with four young children. I being the eldest, was often charged with watching myself between the ages of 7 and 10 (due to the cost and availability of childcare for the other three), and watching the others between 11 and 14.
My dad was gone a lot. Up until I was 10 years old I don't remember ever living with him. He spent all his time and money drinking, doing drugs with his cousins, and who knows what else. When he was around though (he would often come around when the money was gone until his next paycheck, or to stay with us a few days)he was emotionally abusive. He was constantly calling us stupid, fat, ugly, pointing out our physical faults such as acne, or telling us to go play in the freeway (with the connotation that brings). He was also the same way to my mom, and in many ways, his treatment of my mom is what bothered me the most growing up. Later on when he did finally live with us, the abuse continued, and when one time he had his hand up and threatening to hit me because I wasn't cleaning as fast as he wanted, I dared tell him not to touch me and I was yelled at by both my mom and dad and sent to my room crying for hours.
He did a lot of stupid things, smoking marijuana in our house, playing around with my brother one time by putting a pair of scissors to his finger and pretending he was going to cut him- only he actually ended up cutting him (then sending me to my room when I made a remark that he hurt him), showing up drunk on our doorstep after my mom had finally got fed up enough with his bs to kick him out-then laying down on the porch saying "maaaama, let me in the house pleeeease" with absolutely no shame in front of all us kids.
Despite the misery I can remember about my childhood, I love my mom, and I know she did the best she could. I understand now she kept him around because she didn't want to be alone, and she did have feelings for him despite their troubles. As a kid I didn't understand at all, I hated him(still have very strained feelings toward him, although I don't have the same heat behind them as I once did. We haven't had more than a three word conversation since I left home at 18).
I can't even imagine raising four children, let alone as a single mother with no education and little family support. My mom always tried to do stuff for us. Sometimes I would come home to find something I'd been wanting for a long time sitting on my desk after school, or she would tell us we were going to visit a relative or to the DMV, and really we'd park in front of Chuck E. Cheese. We were poor and couldn't afford much, but she took on extra, unpaid part time jobs so we could participate in activies. She volunteered at the park and rec center so we could get into programs for free, and go on field trips for free. She volunteered to lead the childrens program at our church for a while because it was going to be shut down since no one wanted to lead it.
I am extra defensive of my son because of how my dad treated us when we were young, sometimes I can admit I go overboard, but he is my only child, and completely defenseless in my eyes. I do no allow anyone to call him names, I do not allow anyone to make fun of him, if someone hurts his feelings I make sure they know it and apologize. My world revolves around him and I know that makes some parents sneer in derision, but I don't want him to grow up with the issues I did. I had absolutely no confidence, no backbone, no strength, I had no one to back me up or support me, I had no one to turn to when I was feeling down or when the kids at school were terrorizing me.
I feel like I am giving him a sense of security that he will be able to sound off of when he is feeling unsure, something I never had.